RSF’s Press Freedom Prize 2016 goes to the ’64 Tianwang website’ in China.

December 1, 2016

The Hong Kong Free Press (HKFP) of 12 November 2016 carried a fascinating report on the work of the Chinese “64 Tianwang citizen news site” which has continued to operate despite the continued arrest and detention of its reporters. Reporters Without Borders (RSF) awarded ’64 Tianwang’ its Press Freedom Prize 2016. The piece by Catherine Lai is richly illustrated by pictures. Tianwang founder Huang Qi throughout the interview remains remarkably optimistic about freedom of expression in China in the long-term.

Huang Qi. Photo: Huang Qi.

Huang Qi (in black) investigating a forced demolition in Chongqing in October. Photo: Provided by Huang Qi.

In 1998, 64 Tianwang started out under a different name as an organisation that focused on human trafficking, which Tianwang founder Huang Qi described as a “serious problem in the late 1990s.” The site was established the next year. Huang Qi, a Sichuan resident, founded the project with money from his previous career as a businessman and factory owner. “As we were helping these people who had got lost or separated from their loved ones or who had gone missing, we discovered that in the mainland, behind these cases were judicial corruption or human rights infringements, so we expanded our work,” Huang Qi told HKFP. At the time, their work earned Tianwang positive coverage from mainland media, including from the People’s Daily. Later on, they attracted official disapproval for their reporting on human rights.

Now, Tianwang is an independent news site that posts articles and information about human rights incidents in China, including detentions by police, forced demolitions, petitioner activism and demonstrations. Although the site is blocked in China, Huang thinks it is still reaching domestic readers. “They have all sorts of tools to get around the blocks… and they have their own ways of sharing posts,” he said. The site is read by thousands of Chinese citizens, rights organisations, foreign media, and government officials and police – some who are wary of the site reporting their misdeeds and others who are hoping for things to change.

Huang even stood up for the rights of disgraced official Zhou Yongkang, calling for the authorities to protect his rights and not to treat him as a scapegoat. “We hope that in mainland China, everyone will have an equal judicial environment, and that [they] will not use double standards to deal with Chinese officials.”

tianwang huang qi

Huang Qi celebrating with Tianwang volunteers after being released from prison in 2011. Photo: Supplied by Huang Qi.

Huang told HKFP before the Press Freedom award was announced that the award is a way to recognise the work of their volunteer citizen journalists. Nine of their citizen journalists are currently detained and five are on bail, according to Tianwang. Six Tianwang citizen journalists were detained for their coverage of the G20 summit in Hangzhou in September; one of them is still detained. Since its founding, more than a thousand of its citizen journalists have been detained, said Huang. He was last detained for 24 hours at the end of October, as the Sixth Plenum convened in Beijing.

Despite the continued crackdown, Huang Qi and his volunteers have continued their work. When asked if he was worried about increased suppression if Tianwang receives the award, Huang said: “In 18 years, we’ve met with many kinds of suppression, but we’ve never yielded. We also think that this kind of suppression is a necessary condition to help us grow and help us perfect our work.”

64 tianwang

A photo of a protest in China. Photo: 64 Tianwang.

In 18 years, no 64 Tianwang volunteer has ever agreed to sign a confession drafted by the authorities,” he said. “The main reason they haven’t confessed is that they themselves believe that what they’re doing is right…. Their actions are in accordance with the charter of the People’s Republic of China and its related laws, and Xi Jinping’s principle of the rule of law, and the principle of a harmonious society,”.

He told state media in 1999 that Tianwang would become a media organisation on par with outlets like the Washington Post, the Associated Press, Agence France-Presse, and CNN. When asked if he had attained this standard, he said: “Right now, our standard is still very poor, because we have poor material conditions and we constantly meet with suppression. But in the future, we will definitely do a great job.”

Huang was previously jailed for five years for subversion in 2003 after hosting on his site articles about the 1989 pro-democracy movement in China that resulted in the Tiananmen massacre. He was again jailed for three years for “possession of state secrets” after investigating allegations that poor construction contributed to the deaths of schoolchildren in the 2008 Sichuan earthquake.

I’m scared of being sent back to jail too, but so many people are suffering worse than us. And our work can help alleviate their suffering,” he said. “We also believe that Chinese society will finally progress towards democracy and rule of law.”

Despite the authorities’ suppression of their work, Huang remains optimistic – to some, maybe, unreasonably so. Huang insists that the human rights situation is improving in China if viewed in the context of wider trends as opposed to individual cases, even though human rights organisations have said that the situation is deteriorating under current president Xi Jinping. “The human rights situation in mainland China has changed hugely in the past 18 years… I think that eventually – at worst in eight or ten years – China will achieve real press freedom.

2 Responses to “RSF’s Press Freedom Prize 2016 goes to the ’64 Tianwang website’ in China.”

  1. […] Chinese authorities must immediately and unconditionally release citizen journalist and human rights defender Huang Qi, a group of 14 NGOs (and not the least, see below) said on November 5, 2018. Huang Qi (黄琦), the founder and director of 64 Tianwang Human Rights Center, is not receiving adequate medical care in detention and his health has seriously deteriorated, according to his lawyer who visited him on October 23. Huang’s condition is so serious that there is an immediate threat to his life. [see also:…] […]

  2. […] Eight members of the Club’s press freedom committee have resigned in protest over the decision. Shibani Mahtani, Washington Post’s Southeast Asia and Hong Kong Bureau Chief, is one of the resignees. As one of the winners of the Human Rights Press Awards in 2020, Shibani Mahtani expressed her regrets about the decision and explained, in a Twitter thread, the significance of the annual occasion in Asia: See also:… […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: